Home
Shaenon K. Garrity
This is where I write stuff.
 

Advertisement

Customize
14th-Aug-2008 06:27 pm
Atagoul
Food is what you put in children's books instead of sex.

It's hardly a new observation, but I was reminded of it again while rereading The Twenty-One Balloons, a book I loved as a kid. It's about a utopian island community built on the principle of "restaurant government." Everyone on the island owns a restaurant, and the main social activity is going around to all the restaurant/homes for meals. (The book was written in 1947, and the narrator goes on about how weird and foreign and icky the food at the Chinese restaurant is. How did the Greatest Generation survive without delicious Chinese food? I ask you.) Large chunks of the book are devoted to describing the elaborate dining system and the food everyone eats, right up to the climax where the island blows up and they're forced to survive for weeks on sauerbraten and hot chocolate. Again, I loved this book.

Other great moments in children's food porn:



Alice in Wonderland. "Eat Me" and "Drink Me." The mushroom. The tea party. The tarts. It's all about mathematics, sexual repression, and food, but mostly food.

The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. Edmund sells his soul for Turkish Delight, inspiring countless children of later generations to fantasize about the wonders of this actually kind of nasty confection.

Charlotte's Web. Loving descriptions of Wilbur's slop and everything contained therein. The buttermilk bath. Another seduction scene: Templeton agrees to save Charlotte's eggs in return for first crack at Wilbur's trough for life. Oh, Wilbur! Such sacrifice! Also, the cold sarsaparilla at the end of Stuart Little always sounded good to me, as did the watercress sandwiches that Louis orders from room service in The Trumpet of the Swan.

The Oz books. Totally obsessed with the physical process of eating. Characters are constantly threatening to devour each other. The biological and non-biological characters argue about whether it's better not to need to eat. The fixation finds its Platonic expression in the Hungry Tiger, who wants to eat everything and everyone and is in constant agony because decency prevents him from eating fat babies. All he wants is a fat baby, dammit! Just one fat baby! And then a million more.

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. Duh. Actually, all of Roald Dahl's children's books have amazing food scenes. I remember being hypnotized by his mouth-watering description of a cold meat pie, something I'm sure I would have turned up my nose at had I been presented with one in real life, in Danny, the Champion of the World. As Alison Bechdel noted, it gets downright pornographic in James and the Giant Peach.

The Secret Garden. Roasted potatoes for the win. Because everything tastes better if eaten with a sylvan nature boy of the wild moors.

The Neverending Story. No, Bastian! You're planning to live in the school attic indefinitely! Don't eat your whole damn sandwich and apple in one go! No, not even if Atreyu is eating in the book! Have some self-control, you fat basNO BASTIAN NOOOO

Harriet the Spy. I was always impressed that Harriet got cake and milk every single day after school. Truly she is my model of perfect womanhood.

Lizard Music. The hero's progression from borderline pod person to rebel who walks with crazy homeless guys and talking lizards is symbolized by his desire to stop eating TV dinners and cook for himself. You had better believe that Daniel Pinkwater knows how to eat.

The Harry Potter books. J.K. Rowling knows how the game is played. From the first lunch of candy and Cauldron Cakes on the train to the banquets with their tureens of buttery peas to that thrilling first butterbeer, Hogwarts is a horn of plenty, not to mention a contrast to the Dursley household, where Harry never gets enough to eat. You can name at least five brand-name wizard delicacies of the top of your head, can't you?

I can't even get into books for younger readers because there's too many out-and-out food orgies to list. Maurice Sendak's In the Night Kitchen is probably the most notable for its raw fusion of prepubescent hunger, sexuality, and id. You can always turn away, go for the folksy charm of a Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs, but Sendak's still there, staring straight into the Easy-Bake belly of the beast.

Comments 
15th-Aug-2008 02:24 am (UTC)
The Redwall books also have many very vivid and glorious feasts.
15th-Aug-2008 02:28 am (UTC)
Oh, and how could I forget. The Phantom Tollbooth has some very lovely "words as food" instances, the best of which is the feast with King Azaz (the Unabridged) of Dictionopolis. And the frantic and often delicious word market.
15th-Aug-2008 02:29 am (UTC)
Oh, food. *sigh* As an adult, I've been forced to turn to xxxHolic in order to get hungry in that way that only food porn can inspire.
15th-Aug-2008 09:49 pm (UTC)
Antique Bakery. Read it. Love it. Develop a deep need to find a bakery that makes dishes that beautiful.
15th-Aug-2008 02:29 am (UTC)
Hah, I clicked through just to say that theory puts a new spin on Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs, and there it is.

Lizard Music is one of those "oh, shit, I thought I was the only one who read this" books.
15th-Aug-2008 08:34 pm (UTC)
Daniel Pinkwater is a golden god.
15th-Aug-2008 02:34 am (UTC)
I wonder if it's typical of English lit only? When you look at Le Petit Prince you find yourself in a caretesian worlds, with no food.
15th-Aug-2008 02:38 am (UTC)
The Hundred and One Dalmations.

The chapter on when they go to the old Courtly Spaniel's home and they eat hot tea and buttered toast.

And a ton of other references as well.

The Hobbit... lots of food there.

Fat Men from Space by Pinkwater - aliens come to steal our fast food and potato pancakes.

The Witches by Dahl - it has a wonderful description of rowing out to the Shrimp fishermen's boats and eating hot shrimp fresh cooked after being hauled out of the sea.

Oh! and Fantastic Mr. Fox also by Dahl!

Oh, there are so many...
15th-Aug-2008 02:41 am (UTC)
The Pippi Longstocking stories will always be associated with coffee in my mind.
15th-Aug-2008 07:26 am (UTC)
Rolling out cookies on the kitchen floor. And pouring sugar between the toes. (Or was the sugar just a movie-only trope?)
15th-Aug-2008 02:44 am (UTC)
I remember finding In the Night Kitchen weirdly disturbing as a kid, and not being able to pin down why. I think the combination of food and sexuality was what clinched it; it made me feel a bit queasy and yet fascinated at the same time.
15th-Aug-2008 02:45 am (UTC)
I read Twenty-One Balloons when I was in grade school! Man, I didn't remember the Restaurant Government at all, just that the island had all sorts of fancy "world of tomorrow" gadgets going on and that nobody coveted the diamonds because they were too many to have a stable economy based on them. Good read!

Also, I vised Seattle about a year ago and found a place that sold Turkish Delight, and got some just to see what the deal about it was. I concluded that it wasn't too bad, but I wouldn't be selling my family for it anytime soon. I always imagined it being a kind of amazing chocolate-and-cream confection, to be honest. The truth is kind of boring.

The Boxcar children kind of had that going on too, didn't they? I used to be part of a Scholastics book club for it, and the books would come with recipes and everything.
15th-Aug-2008 04:47 pm (UTC)
We had a very long comment thread on Metaquotes once that started out somewhere else and turned into a commiseration that we'd all been duped into thinking Turkish Delight was this amazing creampuff sort of thing and wasn't.
15th-Aug-2008 02:56 am (UTC)
This post is full of win, and that's just for the asides;

All he wants is a fat baby, dammit! Just one fat baby! And then a million more.

Have some self-control, you fat basNO BASTIAN NOOOO

...Sendak's still there, staring straight into the Easy-Bake belly of the beast.
15th-Aug-2008 02:56 am (UTC)
So is Green Eggs and Ham about...experimentation?

"Would you like them on a boat, would you like them with a goat..."
15th-Aug-2008 02:59 am (UTC)
I'm all hungry now, you bitch. :-)


*raids the kitchen*
15th-Aug-2008 03:00 am (UTC)
I didn't think about children's literature as food porn, until you described it that way. It makes sense!

I always understood children's literature as power porn. Most children's books, as I recall, are about the powerless (children) getting power over the powerful (usually, not always adults.)

15th-Aug-2008 06:59 am (UTC)
Now I understand why I've found House of Stairs to be such a powerful novel! It sets the heroes in a situation where they have to choose between food porn and power porn.
15th-Aug-2008 03:13 am (UTC)
Island of the Blue Dolphins, my favorite as a kid, has some great castaway fare.
15th-Aug-2008 03:34 am (UTC)
Anonymous
This puts 'The Fair is a Veritable Smorgasbord' song from the Charlotte's Web cartoon in a whole other light....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tOt_X718SQ
15th-Aug-2008 07:20 am (UTC)
GET OUT OF MY BRAAAAAIN. Damnedly earwormy childhood memories.
15th-Aug-2008 03:37 am (UTC)
A Horse and His Boy had a segment where Shasta (ahem) had his first proper Narnian Bread experience - with butter! As opposed to oil, which the Calormenes used. Perhaps something about miscegenation?

Except, of course, A Horse and His Boy does involve him marrying the Calormene girl at the end...
15th-Aug-2008 03:38 am (UTC)
[...]the watercress sandwiches that Louis orders from room service in The Trumpet of the Swan

I remember reading that before I knew what watercress was. It sounded very exotic. And even now, I've got two quite separate mental representations of watercress—one ordinary one that corresponds to the watercress I've encountered in salads, and one magical one that reminds me that guests are not permitted to play brass instruments in their rooms.

15th-Aug-2008 04:17 am (UTC)
Holy crap. You're right. Oh my god. My brain is explodi -- hrrk!
15th-Aug-2008 04:40 am (UTC)
I used to get SO HUNGRY reading the Narnia Chronicles. The way C.S. Lewis would go on about sausages... gah.

Of course, as adults, we get to have the best of all possible worlds: food smut and regular smut combined! Chocolat, Water for Chocolate, Antique Bakery. Goddamn Antique Bakery. I think I gained four pounds just READING the first chapter, let alone the desserts I was driven to devour afterward.
15th-Aug-2008 04:47 pm (UTC)
And mushrooms. Oh, the mushrooms.
15th-Aug-2008 05:06 am (UTC)
I have yet to try the Turkish Delight I bought while overseas. I don't want to ruin my perfect mental imprint of the thing.
15th-Aug-2008 05:20 am (UTC) - Children's books and food
"The Series of Unfortunate Events"

Each book has at least one menu with recipes.
15th-Aug-2008 05:45 am (UTC)
XD

Bertie Bott's Every-Flavor Beans
Drooble's Best Blowing Gum
Tooth-flossing String Mints
Honeyduke's Chocolate
Chocolate Frogs

Rowling mentioned in an interview once, that (when reading) getting an exact description of the food that characters ate was something that she always found very satisfying as a child.
15th-Aug-2008 07:15 am (UTC)
Cold sarsaparilla is one of the great pleasures of life. Sure, it's just fancy root beer, but that name! Also, it inevitably comes in a completely weird bottle, which counts for a lot when you're 10.

Lizard Music is also one of the great pleasures of life.
15th-Aug-2008 07:17 am (UTC)
Well-made Turkish Delight is actually quite lovely stuff. (Even when your candy thermometer fails, and you end up more with Turkish gummy glop. Uh. Yes.)

And I distinctly remember needing to stop reading parts of both The Hobbit and Fellowship of the Ring because I was craving things I either couldn't access (toasted mutton) or couldn't find analogues to (like the refreshing drinks at the Elvish feasts), and the cravings drove me batty.
15th-Aug-2008 07:24 am (UTC)
Oh, how the hell could I forget all the back-to-nature recipes of Jean Craighead George's My Side Of The Mountain? It was half-survival, half Mother Earth recipes. Acorn pancakes, and homemade jam, and boiled dogtooth violet bulbs, with I-forget-what-kind-of-bark boiled dry in a can for salt. It all seems unrealistically convenient now, but I fell so in love with it. Om nom nom.
15th-Aug-2008 10:40 am (UTC)
Oh, man, Pinkwater is so about the food it's not even funny. If the Bermuda Triangle Chili Parlor existed here in my home city I would be going there all the freakin' time.
15th-Aug-2008 08:37 pm (UTC)
Me too. I'd hang out and telepathically trip people.
Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>

Advertisement

Customize
This page was loaded Jul 10th 2009, 7:18 am GMT.