You are viewing shaenon

Shaenon K. Garrity
This is where I write stuff.
Overlooked Manga Festival 
1st-Jul-2006 12:14 am
Atagoul
I have a confession: my news post on Thursday was actually written by Andrew, using my name, because I was too drunk to do it. As a consequence of my consumption of an entire bottle of Davenport Red sweet table wine (thanks, Annenchen!) to celebrate the release of Narbonic Volume 3, I was unable to write the next installment of my Overlooked Manga series. This has now been remedied. Click past the cut for...Shaenon's Overlooked Manga Festival!



This week's manga gets a thumbs-up from my good buddy and fellow manga addict Jason Thompson, even though he was never a preteen girl, so you know it's gotta be good.



Old-lady otaku like me are probably familiar with Please Save My Earth through the six-episode anime, which was in heavy rotation on the con circuit back when very little anime had been released in English. (I know, I know, it's hard to believe, but there really was a time when this stuff wasn't running 24/7 on the Cartoon Network.) I recall the anime being decent, if totally angsty, but it's extremely truncated and pales beside the epic 21-volume manga.

Okay, the plot, for those of you who aren't old-lady otaku. A teenager named Alice learns that two of her classmates have been having strange dreams about the moon. Soon afterwards, she dreams that she's a woman named Mokuren, living on the moon with a man named Shion. Eventually, Alice and her trippy new friends find a whole group of teenagers who have had the "moon dreams," and they work out the truth: they're the reincarnations of alien scientists who all died while stationed on Earth's moon. Shut up, it makes total sense.

At first, exploring their past lives is almost like a game (or like an RPG -- that's why Jason likes it! Ha ha!). But complications arise, mostly through Rin, the most troublesome member of the group. All the other moon dreamers are teenagers, but Rin is only eight years old. There's a reason for this, and it drives much of the story, as the group gets caught up in old cycles of jealousy and revenge, and the messes left behind in their previous lives catch up to them. It's so karmic.



In fact, PSME is so great that I love it even though it features both of my least favorite things in shojo manga: the useless, passive heroine and the asshole "bad boy" love interest. Actually, in PSME the romantic lead is SO bad that he doubles as the psychotic, world-threatening villain of the piece. It's pretty dysfunctional. And Alice is a totally limp little Mary Sue, crying at the drop of a damn hat. Okay, if people tried to get me engaged to an eight-year-old, I'd be upset, but I wouldn't CRY about it. Sheesh.

And yet the story is totally compelling, and I'll be damned if Saki Hiwatari doesn't make me care desperately about these characters and the problems that are mostly their own damn fault. On a story level, a couple of things really impress me. One is the overall care shown to the plotting. The plot is fairly complex and subtle by manga standards (which, admittedly, ain't saying much), and Hiwatari keeps it together over the course of the story (or at least up to Volume 16, which is as far as I've read; maybe it all falls apart in the final volumes, like so many manga do). The other is the characterization. Hiwatari manages to get across the idea that the moon researchers and the Japanese kids really are the same people, even though they're in different bodies, are at drastically different levels of maturity, and, in some cases, are the opposite gender. (Yeah, like a shojo manga isn't going to go there.) It's amazingly well-done, and as the changes the characters have undergone from one life to the next become clearer, it becomes really poignant. She does an eerily good job of making Rin look like an adult inhabiting the body of a child (oh, and did I mention that everyone has PSYCHIC POWERS?):



As a matter of fact, the manga is so weirdly plausible that Hiwatari started getting letters from crazed fans convinced that they, too, were reincarnations of the moon people. Eventually the publisher had to put a disclaimer on every volume of PSME stating that it was strictly a work of fiction. Seriously, the manga needed a disclaimer to stop readers from FORMING A CULT BASED ON IT BEING REAL. Not even Spider-Man has that level of fandom.

Also, I just want to say that Hiwatari may be the nerdiest manga artist I've come across. She's obviously a giant manga fangirl, and in the early volumes of PSME she works in tons of references to her favorite obsessions, especially Saint Seiya--known in America as Knights of the Zodiac, and also as one of the manga I, Shaenon K. Garrity, edit for Viz. You can pretty much always get on my good side with hilarious Saint Seiya jokes. Here, for example, in a moment that overwhelmed me with radness, Alice and Rin appear as Phoenix Saint Ikki and Andromeda Saint Shun, for no good reason:



And I know it's a hotly contested race, but Hiwatari might also take the prize for most deranged-looking manga self-portrait:



Anyway, the good thing about this manga nerdiness is that Hiwatari steals from some excellent sources. It's pretty obvious that she's a fan of the great shojo creator Moto Hagio, everybody's favorite manga artist what don't get no respect here in the land of wind and ghosts, and PSME seems to borrow a lot of its sci-fi elements and alien culture from Hagio's work. The art is a little Hagioriffic, too. This two-page spread, for instance, is totally kickin' it Year 24 style:



So that's Please Save My Earth. It's pretty solid. Plus you learn a lot about flowers. Flowers and death pacts.



Comments 
1st-Jul-2006 09:50 am (UTC)
Wow! Where'd you find out that awesome factoid about the crazed fans? I sort of suspected it from her artist's notes, but I wasn't sure... maybe I didn't read it closely enough. Is there some cool article about Hiwatari somewhere?
1st-Jul-2006 07:59 pm (UTC)

I kind of deduced it from the weird "This is a work of fiction" notes that started appearing after a certain point, and Wikipedia confirmed it. And Wikipedia is NEVER WRONG, right?
16th-Nov-2007 06:13 pm (UTC)
It's also written up in the 1/4 column author notes, in the volume the note first appears in.

---L.
1st-Jul-2006 10:41 am (UTC)
That's some fairly awesome artwork, especially that two page spread.
Now cut that out! Sheesh, I don't have time for a new addiction, dammitall. Evil, I swear.
1st-Jul-2006 01:12 pm (UTC)
Actually, that bottom page looks a lot like Denise Jone's work from Eversummer Eve.


Hmm..I wonder how that's going? I should go look.
1st-Jul-2006 01:37 pm (UTC)
And I know it's a hotly contested race, but Hiwatari might also take the prize for most deranged-looking manga self-portrait

I think Hiroshi Aro's little alligator is definitely up there. Not a lot of manga-ka drawing themselves as dangerous predators.
1st-Jul-2006 01:51 pm (UTC)
And, well, there's more than one way to read Akira Toriyama's gas mask.
1st-Jul-2006 06:22 pm (UTC)
how about when he draws himself as one of the titular extraterrestrials from the Aliens movies?
16th-Jul-2008 09:44 pm (UTC)
(Seen 13 October Gosford Park When Ian McKellen stepped up to the podium at the Golden Globes (unfortunately not to receive one himself), he quipped that he was the only British actor not to appear in Gosford Park.
16th-Jul-2008 10:40 pm (UTC)
...sorry, but how is that remotely related to what was being discussed in this thread of comments? O_o
17th-Oct-2008 05:39 am (UTC)
(Seen 9 July Gosford Park When Ian McKellen stepped up to the podium at the Golden Globes (unfortunately not to receive one himself), he quipped that he was the only British actor not to appear in Gosford Park.
1st-Jul-2006 01:51 pm (UTC)
What the hell? One bottle of wine is just enough to start posting on.
(Deleted comment)
1st-Jul-2006 08:17 pm (UTC)
And someone tell VIZ they really, really should reprint A A' Prime and They Were Eleven. C'mon, they know one little volume won't hurt. And publish more Moto Hagio manga [even her recent stuff!]

Don't I know it! My dream editing project is Otherworld Barbara, her recently-completed series. I'd also love to do The Poe Family, or any of her old stuff, really. I'm far from the only Viz editor who'd leap on an opportunity to work on a Hagio manga, though.
1st-Jul-2006 04:46 pm (UTC)
PSME was absolutely one of my favorite OVAs, even if the final episode felt like "Oh crap, we only have ten minutes left QUICK END IT." The music gets regular rotation in my MP3 list. Love it.

Now I want to read the manga. Curse yooooou.
1st-Jul-2006 10:24 pm (UTC) - A new series to look up, Yay!
You're welcome - and now we know where Dave gets it from.
2nd-Jul-2006 09:41 pm (UTC)
I thought you didn't drink! That was the ONLY thing keeping me from coming over and mixing batch after batch of bloody marys! Well, that and the 3,000 miles between us.
3rd-Aug-2006 12:41 am (UTC)
Oh YES. Please Save My Earth is my absolute favorite manga ever. I am TOTALLY a reincarnated Moon Person! So I never went that far, but I do love it. Hiwatari is publishing a sequel right now, and it is the most adorable thing I have seen in my short life. She's gotten a whole lot better.
7th-Aug-2006 12:45 am (UTC)
So, I'm a bit behind on my correspondence. But I had to come back over here and say...you were drunk...? Since when do you...drink...? I distinctly remember (Well, not really, because I was blasted) you being the only sober one at your wedding.

And, yeah, I owe you an email. Just as soon as I finish this project, and call my parents and email my grandmother.
16th-Oct-2007 08:39 am (UTC)
Anonymous
I love only this her work (PSME). Her art rise to her peak. After this work, her art line look unstable and her theme still struggle to reincarnation ,and sci-fi/fantasy.

In this work, she draw some characters in "Knight of Zodiac" cloth. It's gorgeous.
16th-Nov-2007 11:26 pm (UTC)
I love, love, love Please Save My Earth. Her more recent works, Mirai no Utena and Global Garden both deal with a lot of the same themes. She seems to really like the whole reincarnation plot.
14th-Mar-2009 03:03 pm (UTC) - Thank you!
Anonymous
This is going to seem a little strange, but I've read and love PSME, and I searched the WHOLE INTERNET for Mokuren's full name. This site is a miracle. The first picture of the manga that's up there has her full name. I was going crazy trying to remember it. Whoever is responsible for this development, my humble thanks and praise! You saved my sanity.
15th-Mar-2009 11:06 pm (UTC) - Re: Thank you!

Finally, my LiveJournal has been a force for good!
This page was loaded Dec 25th 2014, 1:33 am GMT.